How to Make Healthy Chocolate Peanut Butter Candy

How to make healthy chocolate peanut butter candy from scratch.

I admit it, I'm addicted to chocolate. As vices go, it isn't a terrible one, right?

So when I came across a recipe online with a promise of irresistible honey-sweetened chocolates and a photo of cute
perfectly-round candies to prove it, I was excited!

The site is no longer live, so I can't give credit to the creator of the original recipe.

I was intrigued by the idea of making my own chocolate candy cups, and I already had all the necessary ingredients: coconut oil, cocoa, honey, and vanilla extract.

This post includes affiliate links. You can read my full disclosure here.

I made the recipe one afternoon, poured the finished product into silicon muffin cups, set them in the refrigerator to cool and solidify, and waited.

When I took my first bite of the candy I shuddered. Ugh! I obviously hadn't combined the ingredients well enough. The coconut oil had separated from the chocolate and my first bite contained way too much coconut oil.

Now I like the taste of coconut as much as anyone else, but the coconut oil on its own, when I was expecting lovely chocolate, was very disappointing.

Make healthy chocolate peanut butter candy cups.

So I dumped all of the candies back into my saucepan and reheated it all. I added another tablespoon of raw honey, another tablespoon of cocoa, another half-teaspoon of vanilla extract ...

... and a big dollop of creamy peanut butter. Because the only thing that can improve chocolate is peanut butter, am I right?

As soon as the ingredients melted and turned to liquid, I whisked it all together again - really well - and spooned it back into the silicon muffin cups.

This time I was careful to spoon it from the bottom of the pan since the cocoa seemed to settle on the bottom rather quickly, and that coconut oil seemed to float on top.

How to make chocolate peanut butter candy cups.

Back into the refrigerator it went for an hour.

I was cautious when I took my first bite, but those additions made all the difference. It's good! My husband said it's very close in taste to the peanut butter and chocolate candy he likes from the store.

That first batch I made (the one that I remelted and remade) was a dark, rich chocolate color, but the peanut butter in the second batch lightened up the color quite a bit. The texture changed a bit too, but neither change is a deal-breaker in my opinion.

Subscribe to The Acorn, Oak Hill Homestead's weekly-ish newsletter and get my ebook "How to Make Vinegar at Home for Pennies" for free.

The interesting thing is that I ate one, enjoyed it immensely, and had no cravings whatsoever to have another. Amazing!

After all, I'm a chocoholic and I can eat half a dozen chocolate cookies at a time. Eating just one was something foreign to me.

Fewer calories. Healthier ingredients. Win, win.

I used what I had on my pantry shelves, but now I use organic cocoa powder and all-natural, organic peanut butter.

But even with using what was already on my shelves, I'm sure this chocolate peanut butter candy was healthier than a store-bought candy bar. And I didn't have to drive to town on dirt roads for that store-bought candy bar.

I definitely recommend using real vanilla extract though. Sometimes using imitation vanilla extract will cause a recipe to seize up, in other words it will suddenly get stiff, thick and grainy. Unusable. I've had it happen in the past. Not with this recipe, but why take the chance?

Make healthy chocolate candy from scratch.

Here's my tweaked recipe:

Chocolate Peanut Butter Candy
1/2 cup coconut oil
1/3 cup raw honey
3 Tbsp cocoa
1 1/2 tsp pure vanilla extract
3 Tbsp peanut butter

Heat the coconut oil in a saucepan until just melted. Add the raw honey and the peanut butter, stir well to mix. Add the vanilla extract and the cocoa, and whisk until well-combined.

Spoon into silicon muffin cups or a silicon muffin pan (this set includes a mini muffin pan so you can make smaller chocolate peanut butter candy cups).

Refrigerate until solid. Depending on the temperature in your kitchen, you may need to keep them refrigerated until you want to eat one.


This post contains affiliate links. Read my full disclosure here


How to make healthy chocolate peanut butter candy cups in your own kitchen.

This post has been shared at some of my favorite blog hops


My mission is to inspire and encourage you to live a simple, joyful life,
no matter your circumstances or where you live. Join me here:
Facebook | Pinterest | Subscribe | Instagram


  1. I have such a sweet tooth, but try hard not to eat all the chemicals in store bought candy. Thanks for a great alternative!

  2. It's very good, Caitlin, but of course you can tweak it to suit your tastes too. :-)

  3. These look and sound good....and great that they have honey instead of sugar. I, too, have found that the homemade treats don't cause such a "need" for more and more, but a little satisfies. Thank you for the recipe....I plan to try it and am sure my family with love it.

  4. GentleJoy, I think you are right that the homemade "good" ingredients aren't causing further cravings. My silicone cupcake cups make these look like a commercial peanut butter cup - but a whole one is almost too much to eat at one time! I made nine, but I think next time I'll divide it into my 12 cups so they aren't as big. I hope you and your family like these.

  5. Oh my gosh! I'm 6 months pregnant and I LOVE chocolate peanut butter! Can't wait to make these!! {}

  6. I'm going to have to make this recipe on a day when my chocolate cravings are especially bad... I'm saving this one for later!

    1. I do the same thing, Danielle!

  7. These sound really interesting and definitely worth trying. We are trying to eliminate as many processed foods from our diet as possible. But a girl still has her cravings!

    1. Yes, a girl does have cravings! :-) In fact, that's why I made them the first time: no chocolate in the house.

  8. These look yummy! Thanks for sharing on Farm fresh Tuesdays, Kathi!

  9. This sounds amazing!! Thanks for sharing it with us at the Homestead Blog Hop!


Thank you for stopping by. I hope you will leave a comment - I would love to hear from you. If you wish to email me instead, please click here. Thank you!