How to Make Ricotta Cheese


How to make delicious homemade ricotta cheese at home.

Several years ago in August, which is National Goat Cheese Month, I challenged myself to make a different kind of cheese from goat milk every week.

Some of the cheeses I'd made before and some were new to me. The kind folks at Hoegger Supply Company, my favorite place to buy goat supplies, provided the cheese cultures and other supplies I used in this challenge.

My Nubian dairy goats - Phoenix, Ziva, Firefly, and Felicity - provided the milk I used to make the cheese, but you don't have to be limited to goat milk.

If you're buying milk from the grocery store though, I recommend that you buy whole milk. Skim and low fat milk won't work as well for cheesemaking.


Making homemade ricotta cheese from goats' milk.


Italian traditional cheese makers used fresh whey to make ricotta cheese. In other words, they were using whey that was left over from making another cheese first. In essence, it was free cheese, made from leftovers.

That's how I'd been making it, using the whey left over when I made farmer's cheese or lemon cheese. I liked the "free" part, but the yield when I made it this way was disappointingly small.

Then I found a recipe for whole milk ricotta in a book entitled Cheese Making at Home and decided to change my ways. This recipe calls for:

  • 1 gallon cold milk - I used raw whole goat milk, but you can use pasteurized whole milk from the grocery store. Don't use ultra-pasteurized milk though; it won't curdle correctly.
  • 1 tsp citric acid (available here at Hoegger Supply Co.)
  • 1 tsp cheese salt (available here at Hoegger Supply Co.)


How to make homemade ricotta cheese.


As you can see, this recipe uses whole milk instead of whey.

You'll need the following equipment to make ricotta cheese:

  • large non-reactive pot
  • spatula
  • thermometer
  • colander or strainer
  • cheesecloth (available here at Hoegger Supply Co. Be sure it's actual cheesemaking cheesecloth, not the gauzy stuff used for crafts or painting. That kind isn't woven tightly enough and will allow the curds to slip through.)

There are a few more items I used but are optional. Read through the directions and decide whether or not you'll need these or if you can substitute with other items you have on hand:

  • a large bowl to catch the whey
  • large rubber band
  • wooden spoon
  • tall pitcher

I mixed all of the ingredients in the pot (milk, citric acid and cheese salt) and stirred.

Making sure it didn't touch the bottom of the pot, I attached my thermometer to the side. My "big" pot barely held one gallon. I wished for a slightly larger one, but my next biggest pot was a large stock pot that didn't allow the thermometer to reach into the milk.

I hoped the milk wouldn't go over the edge for some reason, but fortunately it didn't.


Homemade ricotta cheese: heat the milk to 195°F.


Over medium heat, I warmed the milk to 195°F.

The directions said to stir occasionally so it wouldn't scorch, but that if it was stirred too much the curds would be too fine. I'm the kind of gal that likes to stir so this was hard for me, not knowing the fine point between "enough" and "too much."


You can make ricotta cheese at home from scratch.


Almost there...


Making ricotta cheese: allowing the curds and whey to separate naturally.


It took awhile, but finally the thermometer reached 195°. The directions said I'd be able to see the separation between the curds and whey, and sure enough, I did!

I carefully moved the pot off the burner to set undisturbed for the required five minutes. Goat curds are fragile, so you have to be gentle. That explains the "don't overstir" caution above.


Homemade ricotta cheese: ready to separate the curds from the whey.


After five minutes it looked very promising, much better than the whey ricotta I'd been making.


Separate the curds from the whey gently.


I put the colander in my largest bowl in the sink, and lined it with cheesecloth. Then I used a measuring cup to scoop up the curds and gently transfer them to the colander. Gently!


You can make ricotta cheese at home from scratch.


Now that I've scooped out some of the curds (above), you can better see how it should look.


Separating the curds from the whey, making homemade ricotta cheese.


After the cheese drained a bit in the colander, I gathered the corners of the cheesecloth and used a rubber band to close it up into a bag.

I put my spoon handle through the rubber band and rested the spoon on top of a pitcher - see the close-up photo below. The cheese hung in the pitcher and I let it drain for about an hour. The longer you let it drain, the drier your cheese will be.


Draining the whey from homemade ricotta cheese.


What beautiful cheese! From that one gallon of milk I made close to two pounds - TWO POUNDS - of ricotta cheese and had almost 3 quarts of whey left over.

I suppose I didn't really need to catch the whey when it drained off, but I hate to waste anything. I used some of the whey to make bread, and I've found that the dogs and cats love the excess whey, so none goes to waste.


You can make ricotta cheese at home from scratch.


I've been using this recipe for whole milk ricotta ever since instead of the whey ricotta I used to make. The cheese has a great texture and makes a good amount from a gallon of milk. It was easy to make, and the lasagna I made for dinner with it was absolutely delicious.

This fresh ricotta cheese doesn't contain preservatives and won't keep well, so be sure to use it up quickly. You can store it in a covered container in the refrigerator for about two days.


More cheese


If you're looking for a simple, easy soft cheese to start your cheese making journey, try farmer's cheese, also known as lemon cheese. With just two ingredients - milk and either vinegar or lemon juice - you'll find this a beginner-friendly project. Plus you can use the leftover whey to make the ricotta cheese in this post.

While mozzarella cheese is a bit more challenging to make, it's definitely a cheese that we all love to eat and stretching the curds is rather fun. When you're ready for a new adventure, learn how to make mozzarella cheese in this post.



For more simple-living and back-to-basics posts like this, subscribe to my weekly-ish new"The Acorn", become a member of our Homesteading Community Facebook group, and join me on FacebookInstagram and Pinterest. I'd love to see you there!



You can make ricotta cheese at home from scratch! Just 3 ingredients and some supplies you probably already have on hand.  #selfreliant #selfsufficient



DISCLOSURE: The cheese cultures and supplies I'm using were supplied by


This post has been shared at some of my favorite blog hops.

~~~~~

My hope is to inspire you, and to encourage your homesteading plans and your dreams of a
simple, self-reliant, God-dependent life. You can follow me at: 
Facebook | Pinterest | Instagram | Subscribe

20 comments

Anonymous said...

Wow, your instructions are so clear. The process seems doable even for me. I love that you were able to get 2 pounds of cheese out of a gallon of milk and that the left-over whey is also usable.

Debbie said...

When I clicked through to Hoegger to check on cheese-making supplies, I noticed that they also have essential oils. It is good to have a new source for them.

Kathi at Oak Hill Homestead said...

Thank you, my anonymous reader. :-) The cheese was quite simple to make and wow, very productive (in other words, worth the time to make it!)

Kathi at Oak Hill Homestead said...

Debbie, thank you for pointing that out. They do carry a variety of items.

Heidi @ Pint Size Farm said...

That looks delicious! I would love to try making some different cheeses. So far I have only made farmer's cheese.

Kathi at Oak Hill Homestead said...

This isn't any harder than farmer's cheese, Heidi. You can do it.

susie @ persimmon moon cottage said...

Your ricotta looks delicious! After reading your excellent instructions with pictures, I am thinking of trying to make some ricotta. The way you explained and showed everything was the best ricotta making recipe that I have seen. I do not have easy access to goat milk. Would the recipe and instructions be exactly the same if I used cow's milk?

Kathi at Oak Hill Homestead said...

Hello Susie. Yes, you would use the same directions if using cows milk. Have fun!

susie @ persimmon moon cottage said...

Thanks Kathi!

Kathi at Oak Hill Homestead said...

You're welcome, Susie. I hope if you try making this, that you will let me know how it turns out!

JES said...

Thanks for sharing these goat cheese recipes on the Art of Home-Making Mondays! I am going to try every one of them on our Saanen and Nubian milkers :) Your tutorial is excellent!

Kathi at Oak Hill Homestead said...

Thank you, Jess. :-)

Unknown said...

How fun to do a different cheese each week. The ricotta looks great. Thanks for sharing at Simple Lives Thursday.

Joanne said...

That looks delicious and oh so creamy! I have never tried making homemade cheese... we might have to give that a try.

Carla Burke said...

I think one or both of my does could be pregnant (it's my first time, so not totally sure), and I can't wait to try this - it sounds fabulous!!

Kathi said...

Hi Carla! It's good to hear from you!

Yes, this ricotta is tasty and easy. I sure hope your doe is expecting. 🙂

Melissa said...

Thanks for sharing with us at Farm Fresh Tuesdays Blog Hop! With people looking to make or grow their own food this is a wonderful recipe! You will be one of my features at this week's hop! Be sure to stop by and see your feature and say hello!
Melissa | Little Frugal Homestead

Rose Felton said...

We don't use a lot of Ricotta Cheese. I make lasagna about 2-3 times a year. Can I half this recipe. I'm presuming I can't freeze it.

Kathi said...

Yes, you can halve the recipe. I haven't tried freezing ricotta, maybe someone else here has and can comment?

Rose Felton said...

Thank you Kathi. I will halve the recipe till I hear if I can freeze it or not. I know some cheeses don't do good being froze so don't want to waste any cheese.